The 2024 MLB draft has come and gone. From July 14-16, a total of 615 athletes had their dreams realized as their names were called. While every team had its own strategy and some had more picks than others, it doesn’t necessarily mean they had the best draft.

One challenge that arises in MLB drafts is the unpredictability of prospects. Teams often have to make tough decisions about whether to draft a high school player who might decide to go to college instead, or a college player who could choose to complete their degree on a scholarship. As a result, some highly talented players may slip to later rounds, but that doesn’t guarantee they will ever play for the team that drafted them.

Teams have extensive knowledge about these prospects, often more than what’s available to the public. When a team drafts a high school player, they usually have a good sense of their willingness to sign. With that context, let’s delve into which teams, according to experts, had standout drafts in 2024 and which ones might have missed the mark.

MLB draft 2024 insights: An interesting trend this year was the low number of high school picks in the first round, a historical light.

The Best MLB Drafts of 2024:

Assessment by R.J. Anderson, CBS Sports:

R.J. Anderson from CBS Sports noted a few standout teams for their impressive draft strategies and selections.

Analysis by Adam Wells, Bleacher Report:

Adam Wells from Bleacher Report also highlighted teams that made smart, strategic choices during the draft, impressing many with their picks.

Insights from Gaurav Vedak, SB Nation:

According to Gaurav Vedak from SB Nation, certain teams excelled by focusing on potential future stars and making calculated risks that seemed to pay off.

The Worst MLB Drafts of 2024:

Critique by R.J. Anderson, CBS Sports:

R.J. Anderson from CBS Sports pointed out some teams whose draft decisions left much to be desired, questioning their long-term planning and player evaluation.

Commentary by Adam Wells, Bleacher Report:

Adam Wells from Bleacher Report shared his thoughts on a few teams that appeared to struggle with their draft, missing opportunities to secure promising talent.

Evaluation by Gaurav Vedak, SB Nation:

Gaurav Vedak from SB Nation also discussed teams that perhaps didn’t make the most out of their draft positions, making choices that seemed questionable.

MLB News: In other headlines, fireballers Mason Miller and Garrett Crochet are facing trade rumors right around their first All-Star trip.