My Husband Said I Do the Same Thing to Our Daughter That I’m Banning His Mother For

I (31F) have been with Derek (34M) for nine years, married for five. We have Penny, who just turned seven. Derek’s mom, Carolyn (61F), lives forty minutes away and watches Penny every other Friday while we both work. We’ve never had a reason to question it. Carolyn raised three kids, she’s energetic, she loves Penny – or I thought she did.

About two months ago, Penny started getting quiet on Thursday nights. Not tired quiet. Different quiet. I asked her what was wrong and she said “nothing” in that voice kids use when it’s definitely something. I told myself it was school stress. She was having some trouble with a girl in her class. I filed it away.

Then six weeks ago, Penny came home from Carolyn’s and wouldn’t eat dinner. She sat at the table and pushed her food around and when I asked her if something happened at Grandma’s she said, “Grandma says I’m dramatic.”

I asked her what she meant.

She said she’d cried at Carolyn’s because she wanted to call me and Carolyn told her, “You’re too old to miss your mom. Big girls don’t act like babies.”

I felt something go cold in my chest.

I talked to Derek that night. He said Carolyn grew up different, that she’s not mean, she’s just old-school about toughening kids up. He said HE turned out fine. I told him Penny is SEVEN and “toughen up” is not a parenting strategy, it’s an excuse to make a child feel ashamed for having feelings. He said I was reading into it.

So I let it go.

Two weeks later, Penny’s drawing pictures at the kitchen table and I sit down next to her and ask her to draw her favorite person. She draws me. Then I ask her to draw Grandma Carolyn. She puts her crayon down and says, “I don’t like drawing Grandma.”

I asked why.

She looked at her paper for a second and then she said, “Because Grandma says I’m too sensitive and I don’t want to draw someone who thinks that about me.”

My daughter is SEVEN years old and she has already learned to protect herself from someone who is supposed to love her.

I went to Derek that night and I told him Penny doesn’t go to Carolyn’s anymore, not alone, not until this gets addressed. He looked at me and said I was taking a seven-year-old’s feelings too literally, that kids exaggerate, that I was going to damage his relationship with his mother over “normal grandma stuff.”

And then he said the thing that’s been living in my head for two weeks.

He said, “You know, you do the same thing to her sometimes. You tell her to stop crying and calm down. So what’s the difference?”

My stomach dropped.

Because he’s not completely wrong. I have said that. Not the way Carolyn says it, I don’t think – but I’ve said it. And now I don’t know if I’m protecting my daughter or if I’m just protecting her from someone who does what I do, but louder, and I can’t figure out which one it is, and that’s the part I can’t let go of.

I told Derek we needed to talk about it properly, all of it – Carolyn, me, how we talk to Penny – and he said fine, we’d talk, and we sat down last Sunday and I laid it all out and he listened and when I finished he took a long breath and said –

What He Actually Said

He said, “I think Carolyn loves Penny. And I think you love Penny. And I think you’re both imperfect people who sometimes say the wrong thing to a kid.”

That’s it. That was his conclusion. Moral equivalence, packaged neatly, handed to me like a verdict.

I sat there for a second. I wanted to flip the table. I didn’t.

I said, “Derek. There is a difference between a parent saying ‘okay, honey, let’s take a breath’ in a hard moment and a grandmother systematically telling your child she’s too much every single time she shows up with feelings.”

He said he didn’t see it as systematic.

I asked him when the last time was that Penny came home from Carolyn’s happy.

He didn’t answer that.

He went quiet in the way he goes quiet when he’s losing an argument and knows it but won’t say so. I’ve known this man for nine years. I know that silence. It’s not agreement. It’s not concession. It’s just him waiting for the conversation to end.

So I said it plain: Penny doesn’t go to Carolyn’s alone. Not right now. Not until something changes. And the “something” doesn’t have to be Carolyn becoming a different person. It just has to be us figuring out how to protect Penny in the meantime.

He said, “My mother is going to think you hate her.”

I said, “I don’t hate her. But Penny’s comfort comes before Carolyn’s feelings about my feelings. That’s just how it is.”

The Part I Keep Sitting With

Here’s the thing I can’t shake, though.

Derek’s comment. The “you do it too” thing. I’ve been turning it over for two weeks like a stone I keep finding in my pocket.

Because yes. I have told Penny to calm down. I’ve said “you’re okay” when she was crying and she wasn’t okay, she just wasn’t bleeding. I’ve said “stop” when the crying went on long enough that I felt my own patience thinning out and I didn’t want to deal with it anymore. I’ve done that. I know I have.

The question I keep asking myself is whether that’s the same thing.

And the honest answer is: I don’t know. Not completely.

What I do know is that when I say it, I feel bad afterward. Like I said the wrong thing. I go back to her. I sit with her. I try to repair it. I don’t know if that makes it better or if it just makes me feel better about doing it.

Carolyn doesn’t go back. That’s what Penny’s told me. Carolyn says the thing and then she moves on, and Penny is just supposed to move on too, and if Penny doesn’t move on fast enough, Carolyn says another thing.

That feels different to me. But maybe I’m just rationalizing because I need it to be different.

I called my sister Donna on Monday. She’s got two kids, she’s four years older than me, and she will tell me when I’m being an idiot. I laid the whole thing out for her and when I finished she said, “You’re not an idiot. But you might want to think about why Derek went straight to ‘you do it too’ instead of ‘okay, let’s fix this.’”

I hadn’t thought about it that way.

What Derek’s Defense Is Actually About

Donna’s point was this: Derek grew up with Carolyn. Whatever Carolyn did to him, he absorbed it, normalized it, built his whole sense of “that’s just how families talk” around it. So when I say Carolyn is hurting Penny, what Derek hears is: your mother hurt you and you didn’t even notice.

That’s not an easy thing to hear.

And his defense mechanism is to spread the blame. To say well, you do it too, so it can’t be that bad, so maybe we’re all just imperfect, so maybe this isn’t actually a problem that needs solving.

I don’t think Derek is a bad guy. I want to be clear about that. He’s a good father, most of the time. He shows up. He does the school runs, he knows all of Penny’s friends’ names, he sits through the American Girl movie franchise with actual patience. He loves his kid.

But he loves his mother too, and those two things are crashing into each other right now, and he is handling it by trying to make them not crash. And the way he’s doing that is by making me the variable. If I’m overreacting, there’s no crash. If my standards are too high, there’s no crash. If I’m just as bad as Carolyn, there’s definitely no crash.

I understand it. I don’t accept it.

What Penny Said Thursday

I wasn’t going to include this because it felt too raw to type out, but it’s the thing that made me stop second-guessing myself.

Thursday night, I was putting Penny to bed. We were doing our usual thing, the back scratch, the two questions (best part of your day, hardest part of your day). Her hardest part was that she couldn’t get her zipper to work on her pencil case and she’d had to ask Mrs. Patton for help and she’d felt embarrassed.

Normal kid stuff. Fine.

Then she said, out of nowhere, “Mom, do you think I’m too sensitive?”

I stopped scratching her back.

I said, “No. I think you feel things, and that’s good.”

She said, “Grandma thinks it’s bad.”

I said, “Grandma’s wrong about that one.”

Penny was quiet for a second. Then she said, “She’s wrong a lot, isn’t she.”

And I didn’t know what to say to that because my seven-year-old just said the thing I’ve been dancing around for two months, and she said it like it was obvious, like she’d been sitting with it for a while and had come to her own conclusion, and she just wanted to see if I’d tell her the truth.

So I did.

I said, “Sometimes. Everybody’s wrong sometimes.”

She seemed satisfied with that. She went to sleep.

I sat on the edge of her bed for probably four minutes just looking at her.

Where We Are Now

Derek and I are not in a good place. I want to be honest about that too.

We’re not fighting constantly. We’re doing that worse thing, where everything is fine and nothing is fine. We’re polite. We’re cooperative. We’re parenting together like two people who have agreed not to look directly at the thing in the middle of the room.

I told him last week that I want us to see someone. A therapist, couples, whatever, I don’t care what we call it. He said he’d think about it. That was six days ago.

Carolyn called on Wednesday. I didn’t answer. She left a voicemail that was friendly and normal and asked if Penny wanted to come over this Friday. I haven’t listened to it more than once. Derek knows about it. He hasn’t said anything.

I don’t know what I’m asking for here, exactly. I don’t think I’m a terrible person. But I also don’t think I’m completely clean in this, and I’m trying to sit with that honestly instead of just being righteous about it.

What I know is that Penny is not going to Carolyn’s alone on Friday.

What I know is that my daughter looked at me in the dark on Thursday and asked me if something was wrong with her, and I told her no, and I meant it.

What I know is that I’m going to keep meaning it, even when it’s inconvenient.

Even when it costs something.

Even if it costs a lot.

—

If this one got to you, share it with someone who needs to hear it.